Marginally Creative Writing

In his persuasive LA Times essay “Let There be Dark,” editorialist Paul Bogard shines a little light on our human need for darkness. He argues that ubiquitous light pollution throughout the country is not only reducing our quality of life by depriving the sky of its natural beauty, but also by creating a host of pollution-related health problems.

Bogard employs his own personal experiences to connect with his audience, fondly recalling the profound darkness and starry skies of his childhood home in Minnesota. He talks on how 8 in 10 American children will never know a night sky dark enough for the milky way galaxy. Bogard also quotes the World Health Organization in stating that sleep deprivation caused by light pollution is now known to be a probable carcinogen, and links other disorders such as obesity, diabetes, and depression. He maintains that in a world growing 6% brighter every year, even the world’s ecology is becoming increasingly unstable as the nocturnal creatures that pollinate fields and protect against disease are growing increasingly disoriented. He offers some hope though, in addressing the steps being taken to reduce light emission the world over, such as LED replacements and automatic shut-off switches in large, bright cities such as Paris.

Bogard points out that without darkness, we are losing a natural treasure along the same lines as the Grand Canyon or Yosemite. He warns of the part the every-day consumer plays in the reduction of darkness. Every night, people reach for their devices, light their homes, and turn on their headlights. Bogard concedes that recent changes for good are a result more of a desire to reduce energy consumption, although their side effects are beneficial to the environment. He argues that we will never truly address the problem of light pollution until we become aware of the irreplaceable value and beauty of the darkness we are losing.

Bogard uses powerful and often melodic language when trying to communicate to his readers the country’s dire situation. He recalls days spent under “sugary spreads of stars,” and laments the probability that modern youth will grow up in a world without that sky that inspired works like Van Gogh’s “Starry Night.” He states that “every religious tradition has considered darkness invaluable for a soulful life, and the chance to witness the universe has inspired artists, philosophers and everyday stargazers since time began.”

Paul Bogard, despite obviously holding the subject near his heart, still gives objective and excellent points regarding the invaluableness of darkness. He gives stark predictions on the future of a country enshrouded in light, supported by existing data supporting his thesis that darkness is a necessary part of life. He gives startling links to light pollution and health and ecological problems, and illustrates all the religious and cultural significance of darkness in human history. He ends his essay by positing that the problem of vanishing darkness will never be solved until there is a wide acknowledging of said problem. Ultimately, Bogard hopes for a coordinated effort to stem the rise of light pollution and return to the nation the beauty and calm of the nights our grandfathers knew.


3 thoughts on “Marginally Creative Writing

  1. lianakawczak says:

    I liked the way you worded everything.
    I noticed you used a lot of strong words.
    I wondered how I am supposed to find any mistakes in your writing or have any suggestions when your writing is so good:)
    I would suggest maybe making it a little more clear which paragraph is which. (E) (R) (S) Otherwise, I can’t find anything else.
    Strong words or phrases would be ubiquitous, enshrouded, “sugary spreads of stars”

  2. emmarapp says:

    I noticed- how well the first paragraph drew me into the rest of your essay
    I liked- your creative title and how much information you used from Bogard’s essay
    I wondered- how long it took you to write this remarkable essay
    I would suggest- putting a little more passion into your title
    Strong words or phrases- “Paul Bogard shines a little light on our human need for darkness”

  3. So your title… is that your marginally creative writing or his? I’m thinking you mean you??? But if so I disagree. 🙂 Your opening paragraph shows how well you understand his content and style– and you say it artfully. One suggestion on the 2nd paragraph: I wouldn’t use the phrase “he talks on how…” Perhaps “he calls to mind the fact that…” or “he cites”Your paragraphs rival his own, so I’d say you achieved excellence with this analysis. But not just because you’re able to showcase your vocabulary, creativity, and organizational writing skills in this academic work, but because you also have complex content of your own, as far as the analysis goes.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s